Affliate Disclaimer: When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
Swipe Previous
Swipe Next
Department 56 - Christmas in the City - Scottie's Toy Shop Collectibles for Sale
Year Released: 1998 -- Year Retired: 1998
Collection: Christmas in the City
US Retail 65, CAD Retail 97.5
Size: 6 x 5 x 8.25
Part Number: 56.58871
| eBay Summary - Currency Code: USD | Count | Avg. Price (USD) | Low Price (USD) | High Price (USD) |
| Bid Auctions | 0 | |||
| Buy it Now Auctions | 33 | 61.16 | 20.00 | 142.73 |
Listed below are current active eBay auctions for this collectible.
Click on the image or link to see more details about the auction on eBay.
Current eBay Auctions
Title: Department 56 Scotties Toy Shop Gift Set 1998 58871 - No Light- Not Complete
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $20.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Sheboygan, US
Seller Rating: 995/99.5%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $20.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Sheboygan, US
Seller Rating: 995/99.5%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Dept 56 Scottie’s Toy Shop #58871 Retired 1998 House Only Light Works Tested
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $33.96 or Best Offer
Item location: Greenville, US
Seller Rating: 2358/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $33.96 or Best Offer
Item location: Greenville, US
Seller Rating: 2358/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Dept 56 Scottie’s Toy Shop #58871 Christmas in the City 1998 Retired No Cord
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $35.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Las Vegas, US
Seller Rating: 67/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $35.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Las Vegas, US
Seller Rating: 67/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Dept 56 Heritage Village Scottie's Toy Shop InOriginal Box **Missing Pieces**
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $35.00
Item location: Lakeland, US
Seller Rating: 497/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $35.00
Item location: Lakeland, US
Seller Rating: 497/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Dept. 56 Heritage Village Scottie's Toy Shop 1998 - missing 1 part see descrip.
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $38.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Willow Spring, US
Seller Rating: 162/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $38.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Willow Spring, US
Seller Rating: 162/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Dept 56. Scottie's Toy Shop gift set. In Original Box
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $38.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Melbourne, US
Seller Rating: 1983/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $38.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Melbourne, US
Seller Rating: 1983/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Dept 56 1998 Christmas in the City Scottie's Toy Shop 8.5" 56.58871 Retired!
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $39.55
Item location: Patterson, US
Seller Rating: 1620/98.5%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $39.55
Item location: Patterson, US
Seller Rating: 1620/98.5%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Department 56 Heritage Village Scottie’s Toy Shop Gift Set Retired #58871
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $39.90
Item location: Agawam, US
Seller Rating: 4329/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $39.90
Item location: Agawam, US
Seller Rating: 4329/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Dickens Village "Scottie's Toy Shop" Gift Set Heritage - Dept. 56 58871 With Box
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $39.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Westerville, US
Seller Rating: 534/99.5%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $39.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Westerville, US
Seller Rating: 534/99.5%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Department 56 58871 Scotties Toy Shop Christmas Lighted House Gift Set Complete
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $39.99
Item location: Brooklyn, US
Seller Rating: 1595/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $39.99
Item location: Brooklyn, US
Seller Rating: 1595/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Department 56 Heritage Village Scottie’s Toy Shop Gift Set Retired #58871
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $40.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Sarasota, US
Seller Rating: 6/0.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $40.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Sarasota, US
Seller Rating: 6/0.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Dept 56 CHRISTMAS SCOTTIE'S TOY SHOP & Figures and Fake Snow 1998?
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $41.99 or Best Offer
Item location: New Berlin, US
Seller Rating: 1288/99.7%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $41.99 or Best Offer
Item location: New Berlin, US
Seller Rating: 1288/99.7%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Dept 56 Heritage Village "Scottie's Toy Shop", Box, Not Complete, 1988
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $45.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Pacific, US
Seller Rating: 697/99.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $45.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Pacific, US
Seller Rating: 697/99.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Department 56 Christmas In The City Scottie's Toy Shop #58871 *WORKS* *Read*
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $49.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Albrightsville, US
Seller Rating: 2228/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $49.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Albrightsville, US
Seller Rating: 2228/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Department 56 SCOTTIE'S TOY SHOP HERITAGE SNOW VILLAGE CHRISTMAS 58871
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $50.00
Item location: Lakeland, US
Seller Rating: 2094/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $50.00
Item location: Lakeland, US
Seller Rating: 2094/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Department 56 Scottie’s Toy Shop
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $52.00
Item location: Garden City, US
Seller Rating: 1/0.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $52.00
Item location: Garden City, US
Seller Rating: 1/0.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: DEPT 56 Christmas in the City SCOTTIE'S TOY SHOP Gift set
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $55.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Virginia Beach, US
Seller Rating: 3881/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $55.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Virginia Beach, US
Seller Rating: 3881/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: 1990s Dept 56 Scottie's Toy Shop Light Up Village House, Heritage Village Gift C
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $60.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Windsor, US
Seller Rating: 9/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $60.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Windsor, US
Seller Rating: 9/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: DEPT 56 SCOTTIE'S TOY SHOP HERITAGE SNOW VILLAGE CHRISTMAS 58871
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $60.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Saint Paul, US
Seller Rating: 3396/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $60.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Saint Paul, US
Seller Rating: 3396/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Dept 56 1998 Scotties Toy Shop -Christmas In The City Series Gift Set-New in Box
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $67.25
Item location: Mahopac, US
Seller Rating: 1226/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $67.25
Item location: Mahopac, US
Seller Rating: 1226/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: DEPT 56 CHRISTMAS IN THE CITY "SCOTTIE'S TOY SHOP" #58871 SET /10 BRAND NEW
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $67.96 or Best Offer
Item location: Barnegat, US
Seller Rating: 5040/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $67.96 or Best Offer
Item location: Barnegat, US
Seller Rating: 5040/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Dept. 56 1998 Christmas In The City Scottie's Toy Shop #58871
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $69.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Ringwood, US
Seller Rating: 57/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $69.99 or Best Offer
Item location: Ringwood, US
Seller Rating: 57/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Dept 56 CIC Christmas in the City SCOTTIE'S TOY SHOP Gift Set 58871 GREAT
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $72.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Denver, US
Seller Rating: 83/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $72.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Denver, US
Seller Rating: 83/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Dept 56 Christmas In The City Scotties Toy Shop Set of 10 58871 New Retired
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $74.96
Item location: Conyers, US
Seller Rating: 6203/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $74.96
Item location: Conyers, US
Seller Rating: 6203/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Vintage Dept 56 Snow Village Christmas Large Selection You Pick FREE SHiPPING - Scottie's Toy Shop
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $75.00
Item location: Las Vegas, US
Seller Rating: 478/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $75.00
Item location: Las Vegas, US
Seller Rating: 478/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Dept. 56 Christmas in the City Scottie's Toy Shop
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $75.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Alexandria, US
Seller Rating: 80/98.5%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $75.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Alexandria, US
Seller Rating: 80/98.5%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Dept 56 Christmas in the City Scottie’s Toy Shop CIC Gift set of 10 Retired NIB
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $75.00 or Best Offer
Item location: San Antonio, US
Seller Rating: 37/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $75.00 or Best Offer
Item location: San Antonio, US
Seller Rating: 37/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Department 56 Scottie's Toy Shop Gift Set Christmas in the City Complete 1998
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $84.95
Item location: Berkley, US
Seller Rating: 5263/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $84.95
Item location: Berkley, US
Seller Rating: 5263/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Dept. 56 SCOTTIE'S TOY SHOP Gift Set #58871 NEW w/Free Shipping!
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $85.00
Item location: East Hampstead, US
Seller Rating: 10066/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $85.00
Item location: East Hampstead, US
Seller Rating: 10066/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Dept 56 Christmas in the City Series Scotties Toy Shop Gift Set #
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $90.00 or Best Offer
Item location: West Babylon, US
Seller Rating: 1505/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $90.00 or Best Offer
Item location: West Babylon, US
Seller Rating: 1505/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: NOS Dept 56 Christmas in the City SCOTTIE'S TOY SHOP Gift Set 58871 Retired
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $99.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Bothell, US
Seller Rating: 964/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $99.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Bothell, US
Seller Rating: 964/100.0%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Dept 56, Christmas in the city - Scotties Toy Shop #58871 - Read Description
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $125.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Clayton, US
Seller Rating: 1754/96.5%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $125.00 or Best Offer
Item location: Clayton, US
Seller Rating: 1754/96.5%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Title: Dept 56 Christmas in the City Scottie’s Toy Shop CIC Gift set of 10 Retired NIB
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $142.73 or Best Offer
Item location: Orlando, US
Seller Rating: 4454/99.7%
Click here to see eBay Auction
Currency: USD
Buy It Now Price: $142.73 or Best Offer
Item location: Orlando, US
Seller Rating: 4454/99.7%
Click here to see eBay Auction
This site contains affiliate links for which I may be compensated
Back to the top
Last Updated December 15, 2025, 4:46 am
Copyright © 2025 N. & C. Stevens
Privacy Policy
➤